Reducing Risks and Complexity Associated with Independent Contractors

Contractors were once seen as stopgaps. Now, they’re a strategic element in how companies build dynamic, more adaptive teams, bringing specialized talent on demand and often offering skills that are difficult to consistently maintain in-house. However, simply calling someone a contractor doesn’t necessarily make it so legally, as worker classification rules aren’t universal.

The lines between a contractor and an employee can be delicate, especially across country or state borders. For instance, when hiring contractors from different parts of the world, it’s easy to overlook how factors like working hours or how deeply embedded a contractor is internally could trigger misclassification. When a contractor-client relationship closely resembles an employee-employer one, the risks can be significant: fines, wage audits and even legal disputes.

But while the worker classification is generally complex, some focus and attention here can help you steer clear of misclassification.

Making Sense of Contractor Employment

Expanding contractor hiring to a global scale introduces increased complexity in worker classification — with labor laws, taxation and compliance requirements varying from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. Every country has its own criteria for differentiating employees from independent contractors. This means that what qualifies as an independent contractor in one country may lead to consideration as an employee in another. In India, for instance, a contractor may work exclusively for a single client, while in Spain, those earning at least 75% of their income from one client are classified as “dependent contractors” and granted certain employee-like protections.

If that wasn’t complicated enough, employment laws also are constantly evolving; a worker classified as a contractor today could be considered an employee by the following year, given shifts occurring in individual countries and geographic regions. Managing global contractor compliance requires employers to consistently be aware of law changes.

Several aspects of an employer’s working relationship with the contractor also can influence their classification — some less obvious than the others. While it may seem innocuous to assign detailed tasks or direct how the work is done, these things could lead to the contractor being classified as an employee. When contractors work remotely from different countries, companies often implement communication structures that may unintentionally resemble employee supervision. For example, setting fixed working hours or providing them with tools, equipment or resources beyond what’s outlined in the contract may trigger reclassification, especially in countries with strict worker protection laws. Some situations are more straightforward, like if a contractor begins working exclusively for one company or is hired for an indefinite period, both of which can lead to misclassification.

Companies can find themselves in legal trouble if misclassified contractors later claim they were denied employment benefits or if misclassification is flagged in government audits. Misclassification could invite fines for unpaid taxes and workers’ compensation and hold organizations liable for unpaid wages and benefits such as healthcare and retirement plans.

The Time Is Ripe to Put Effort Here

As contractors become an increasingly integral part of the modern workforce (the independent workforce in the U.S is estimated to range from 11.9 million to 65 million workers), you likely need to put time and effort here to ensure effective, compliant management. Without a structured approach, handling classification can quickly become expensive, complex and time-consuming as teams grow.

A contractor of record (COR) can be one solution to help address some of these issues and burdens. Local legal expertise, contract oversight and continuous assessment of worker relationships are general compliance requirements. A COR can simplify contractor management by handling classification on behalf of the organization, better ensuring compliance with local laws, and making necessary changes if the working relationship evolves further.

In terms of hiring global contractors, a COR may prove invaluable in navigating compliance with local laws and streamlining payments. Paying international contractors can get tricky with fluctuating exchange rates and transfer fees, making it difficult to predict contractor-related expenses and ensure timely payments. When an organization approves an invoice, the COR typically handles the payment, ensuring contractors are paid accurately, on time and in their preferred currency, all while adhering to regional regulations.

Similarly, a COR can address the complexity of manually tracking and ensuring compliance with tax laws in countries from which organizations hire contractors. For instance, in some regions, companies may be required to withhold a fixed percentage for tax purposes if the contractor is classified in a certain way, while in several others, tax obligations fall entirely on the contractor. Regulations can vary based on factors such as residency status, contract type and local tax laws, requiring a comprehensive approach to ensure compliance when hiring globally.

Building Strong Contractor Relationships

When organizations and contractors are confident of classification compliance, it can set the foundation for strong, positive working relationships. Beyond what’s customary by law, it’s also important for companies to build and maintain good relationships with the contractors they hire. While the nature of work arrangements differs from regular employees, the principles of trust, respect and collaboration remain the same. Clear communication and well-defined expectations without treading into micromanagement all create an environment where contractors can do their best work. At the same time, it’s crucial to give contractors the freedom to work independently, respecting their expertise and flexibility. Just as important, paying fairly and on time reinforces credibility and strengthens the relationship.

While working with contractors across borders comes with its challenges, the right management approach, attention and tools can make this workforce approach more efficient and viable.

Editor’s Note: Additional Content

For more information and resources related to this article, see the pages below, which offer quick access to all WorldatWork content on these topics: