Close
Learning Methods
Classroom
A traditional classroom couples on-site learning with the added value of face-to-face interaction with instructors and peers. With courses and exams scheduled worldwide, you will be sure to find a class near you.
Interaction
Highly Interactive
On-going interaction with instructor throughout the entire classroom event
Interaction with peers/professionals via face-to-face
Components (May Include)
Onsite
On-site instructor-led delivery of course modules, discussions, exercises, case studies, and application opportunities
Supplemental learning elements such as: audio/video files, tools and templates, articles and/or white papers
E-course materials available two weeks prior to the course start date; printed course materials ship directly to the event location
Duration
One + Days
Varies by course ranging from one to multiple days
Technical Needs
Specific requirements are clearly noted on the course page
Virtual Classroom
Ideal for those who appreciate live education instruction, but looking to save on travel. A virtual classroom affords you many of the same learning benefits as traditional–all from the convenience of your office.
Interaction
Highly Interactive
On-going interaction with instructor throughout the entire virtual classroom event
Interaction with peers/professionals via online environment
Components (May Include)
Live online instructor-led delivery of course modules, discussions, exercises, case studies, and application opportunities
Supplemental learning elements such as: audio/video files, tools and templates, articles and/or white papers
E-course materials available up to one week prior to the course start date. Recorded playback and supplemental materials available up to seven days after the live event.
Duration
Varies by course ranging from one to multiple sessions
Technical Needs
Adobe Flash Player
Acrobat Reader
Computer with sound capability and high-speed internet access
Phone line access
E-Learning
A self-paced, online learning experience that allows you to study any time of day. Course material is pre-recorded by an instructor and you have the flexibility to view content modules as desired.
Interaction
Independent Learning
Components (May Include)
Pre-Recorded
Pre-recorded course modules
Supplemental learning elements such as: audio/video files, online quizzes
E-course materials start on the day of purchase
Optional purchased print material ships within 7 business days
Duration
120 Days - Anytime
120-day access starts on the day of purchase
Direct access to all components
Technical Needs
Adobe Flash Player
Acrobat Reader
Computer with sound capability and high-speed internet access
Close
Contact Sponsor
E-Reward
Online
Paul Thompson
Phone: 1 44 01614322584
Contact by Email | Website
Close
Sorry, you can't add this item to the cart.
You have reached the maximum allowed quantity for purchase in your cart or the item isn't available anymore.
Product successfully added to your cart!
Price
View your cart
Continue shopping
Please note our website will be down this Friday, November 5 from 9pm ET – 11pm ET for routine maintenance. We apologize for any inconvenience.
WORKSPAN
WORKSPAN DAILY |

Ideas and One-Time Practices Are Not Trends

Editor’s Note: Workspan Daily will be publishing a monthly executive compensation column from Willis Towers Watson for the benefit of our readers and to encourage further discourse on topics vital to compensation professionals. New to WorldatWork? Please feel free to join the discussion in our Online Community or send your thoughts to workspan@worldatwork.org.

We are in a time of significant change in executive compensation. Some of that change is part of important long-term trends, some of it is short-term adaptation to an unusually high-risk environment, and some of it is just talk and ideas. It is our job as executive compensation practitioners to do our best to know the difference.

Image

For example, there were conversations in the corporate governance community in the Fall of 2020 about the viability of stock options as a good incentive vehicle to adopt or expand in these uncertain times. This idea certainly has some merit in that options do not require long-term goal setting and typically have a 10-year life, so they can function through multiple business cycles. However, as of this writing, there has been no resurgence of option use, and no signs of one.

There has also been an article or two suggesting that restricted stock is a good solution in these uncertain times — perhaps with long vesting or holding requirements. Again, this may be a good idea, but so far there are no signs of significant expansion of restricted stock usage in place of performance plans.

These are ideas, not trends.

There is always a temptation to report an idea one hears as an emerging trend, especially if heard more than once and even more so if the idea has logic and merit. It is important that we as executive compensation professionals discuss ideas as ideas, trends as trends, one-time practices as such, and facts as facts.

This is particularly important now as the exec comp landscape is changing rapidly. As trusted advisors and valued sources of information to boards and senior management, practitioners have to be careful not to inadvertently start or feed practices that may not be the best in the long run. While board members make decisions based on the merits of a particular pay practice, they can also be swayed by data on what other companies are doing. And they can be swayed by the thoughts and opinions of their advisors. Executive pay professionals can actually influence the direction of market practices, especially during times of rapid change, where hard data won’t be available for months or longer. Yes, it’s a free market for executive talent, but consultants really do influence that market, at least in the short-term, and have an obligation to do so responsibly.

On that note, some companies have discussed or planned to make larger long-term incentive plan (LTIP) grants in 2021 to partially make up for LTIP performance cycles that were badly hurt, or zeroed-out by the events of 2020. This appears to be more than an idea, and is likely to be a one-time practice by at least some companies. But this is not a trend, meaning that it shouldn’t lead to a sustained increase in LTIP grant levels in future years.

It is very important that these one-time larger grants are one-time events, and do not lead to a permanent increase in competitive market LTIP levels. If a company increases its 2021 grant by 25% for example, to compensate for prior LTIP cycles hurt by the pandemic, then it’s important to record it as such and make sure that grants return to “normal” levels in subsequent years. How these supplemental grants are disclosed and recorded in proxy statements and compensation surveys remains to be seen, but executive compensation professionals should be vigilant in distinguishing them from ongoing annual grants. This may be difficult to do since the supplemental LTIP grants may be made as an increase to the normal annual grants, using the same vehicles and grant timing.

Knowing and discussing the difference between ideas, trends and one-time practices is not a trivial exercise. Executive compensation has seen massive trends rapidly sweep the corporate landscape over the last four decades:

  • Mega-grants in the 1980s, which became common practice.
  • Golden parachutes and gross ups in the 1980s.
  • The stock option explosion of the 1990s.
  • The stock option implosion of the 2000s, when options were rapidly replaced with full value shares and performance plans.
  • The sudden prevalence of relative TSR plans in the 2000s and 2010s.

At least some portion of these and other trends were fueled by boards and management teams following what other companies are doing. There is safety in numbers and wisdom in having a competitive compensation program, but following the herd does not always yield the optimal solution.  

As new practices, ideas and trends emerge in these turbulent times, compensation professionals should do their best to keep one eye on the competitive market, but also focus on what is best for their company and business situation.

About the Author

Don Delves Bio Image

Don Delves is a managing director and North America practice leader, executive compensation, at Willis Towers Watson.


About WorldatWork

WorldatWork is a professional nonprofit association that sets the agenda and standard of excellence in the field of Total Rewards. Our membership, signature certifications, data, content, and conferences are designed to advance our members’ leadership, and to help them influence great outcomes for their own organizations.

About Membership

Membership provides access to practical resources, research, emerging trends, a professional network, and career-building education and certification. Learn more and join today.