For WorldatWork Members
- The Pros and Cons of AI Automation in Hiring, Workspan Daily Plus+ article
- How to Use AI to Improve Your Recruitment Process, Workspan Daily Plus+ article
- Whether or Not You’re Posting ‘Ghost Jobs,’ You Should Take Action, Workspan Daily Plus+ article
- How to Understand What Matters Most to Job Candidates, Workspan Daily Plus+ article
- How to Contend with a Job-Hopping Workforce, Workspan Daily Plus+ article
For Everyone
- Employers, Workers Say Distrust Is a Jobs Market Derailer, Workspan Daily article
- AI Is Taking Over Hiring. What Does That Mean for Total Rewards? Workspan Daily article
- Dangling a Carrot That Doesn’t Exist: The ‘Ghost Job’ Economy, Workspan Daily article
- Young Workers Opting for the Job-Hop Instead of the Climb, Workspan Daily article
- Shifting Priorities? The Relative Importance of Pay to Job Candidates, Workspan Daily article
- Leading Pay Transparency Across Every Market, on-demand webinar
Your loooooong job applications and impersonal touch during the path-to-hiring process are likely driving away top candidates.
Several recent studies reveal job seekers are experiencing unprecedented application strain in the current “low hire, low fire” market. Data points include:
- More than half of millennial and Generation Z job seekers have abandoned an application simply because it was too tedious or time-consuming.
- 92% of interested job seekers who click “apply” never actually finish the task, hindered by mandatory logins, redundant data entry and multi-step forms.
- 58% of applicants are frustrated by having to re-enter information that’s already included on their resume.
On top of this:
- 60% of workers are frustrated by not knowing if a human even viewed their resume. (This is a valid concern since 93% of companies use automated applicant tracking systems [ATS] to screen resumes, 75% of which are rejected before reaching a human recruiter.
- 92% of workers want to cut down on “ghost jobs” by legally requiring companies to disclose whether or not publicly advertised job postings are actually real.
- 58% of candidates have turned down an offer because of poor candidate experience.
- 65% of candidates rarely or never receive an update on their application, and 80% of candidates wouldn’t consider other relevant job listings if a company doesn’t notify them of their outcome.
All in all, it’s a bit of a mess, as job applicants generally view the total experience as exhausting, impersonal and suspicious.
WorldatWork members can access a bonus article on this subject:
AI as Process Angel … or Demon
“Employers still rely on formal job applications, applicant tracking systems, multiple interview rounds, and sometimes tests, writing samples or assessments during the process,” said Vicki Salemi, a career advice expert at employment website Monster. “As job seekers increasingly use artificial intelligence [AI] to build resumes and employers use it to screen candidates, many are wondering whether the hiring process is becoming less human.”
Employers want to recruit top talent while improving efficiency and saving their recruiting teams time; applicants are looking for transparency and communication, Salemi said.
“When I worked in corporate recruiting, candidates sometimes actually thanked me for rejecting them via email or on the phone because they felt they at least received a concrete ‘no’ rather than being ghosted and left hanging after spending time and effort pursuing the role,” she said.
Frustrations can occur at every stage of the hiring process, agreed Sue Holloway, a content director at WorldatWork. At the same time, she said employers are under pressure to fill roles efficiently while managing high application volumes.
“AI is influencing both sides of the process,” Holloway said.
Employers are using automation technologies to support activities such as sourcing talent, reviewing applications, scheduling interviews and improving communications. Candidates are using AI tools to help write resumes and cover letters, and prepare for interviews.
“This creates opportunities for improvements, but also new challenges around authenticity, fairness and trust,” Holloway said.
Two Potential Outcomes
Without improvements, the current employer-applicant clash generally has one of two results:
- Candidates step back from applying; or,
- Candidates amp up their efforts and blast out more resumes than ever.
Either way, it’s a miss — for the candidate and the employer.
“A percentage of the best candidates will opt out of new hoops to jump through, and the lower-qualified candidates will blast far and wide beyond their skill set,” said Neil Costa, the CEO and founder of HireClix, a recruitment marketing agency. “Employers are in a jam.”
When expectations on both sides are misaligned, organizations can lose strong candidates before an offer is ever extended, Holloway agreed.
And, that poor candidate experience can have measurable business consequences, she added.
“Employers may invest significant time and resources in recruiting only to see offers declined, positions remain unfilled longer or new hires prove to be a poor fit,” increasing both hiring costs and retention risk, Holloway said.
What a person sees and feels as a job candidate increasingly is viewed as the first stage of the employee experience, she said.
“The way an organization communicates, demonstrates fairness and builds trust during recruitment can shape an individual’s perception of the employer brand long before their first day on the job,” Holloway said. “This is why leading employers are focusing not just on hiring efficiency but on creating a hiring journey that is transparent, responsive and people-centered.”
Editor’s Note: Additional Content
For more information and resources related to this article, see the pages below, which offer quick access to all WorldatWork content on these topics: