For WorldatWork Members
- Six Sales Comp Vital Signs: An Executive Guide to Reading the Signals, Impact magazine article
- The Four-Step Sales Comp Plan Audit You Need Now Instead of Later, WorldatWork Today article
- Sales Compensation Programs and Practices, research
- Manager Quota Allocation Tool, tool
- Sales Quota Setting Guide, tool
- Sales Performance Management Technology Selection Guide, tool
For Everyone
- Sales Comp Market Alignment: 7 Factors That Influence Pay Positioning, WorldatWork Today article
- Sales, in Black and White: How a Commission Plan Killed a Company, WorldatWork Today article
- 3 AI-Related Shifts Are Rewriting Sales Jobs and Their Compensation, Workspan Daily article
- Beyond Market Data: Building Effective Pay Structures for Sales Jobs, Workspan Daily article
- Sales Compensation Course Series, education
- The 2026 Retro: What Held Up in Incentive Compensation, and What’s Next for 2027, Dec. 10 webinar
Land. Adopt. Expand. Renew.
Predictable subscription revenue depends on getting right all four motions (which form the acronym LAER), but more motions mean more sales compensation measures to choose from. The challenge is deciding what measures belong in your plan.
This article will explain how customer life cycle motions shape compensation measure selection and why annual recurring revenue (ARR) differs from annual contract value (ACV). It also will explore how to encourage multiyear commitments without over-rewarding contract duration.
For committed-subscription, recurring-revenue models, it all starts with the customer life cycle.
The Metrics and Motions
When it comes to one-time solutions, revenue growth often centers on two motions:
- Land new customers; and,
- Expand sales to existing customers by selling more products.
Building a sales compensation measure involves deciding on what metric and motion to use:
- Metric consideration: Bookings or revenue
- Motion consideration: New logo, install base or total (new logo and install base)
Subscription, recurring-revenue models add “adopt and renew” to “land and expand,” creating the full LAER framework. To drive revenue growth, companies must land a customer, drive adoption and attain value realization, which lays the foundation for expansion and renewals. The number of sales compensation measures expands dramatically based on the metric and motion:
- Metric: ARR, ACV and total contract value (TCV)
- Motion: New, expand, renewal, total, total net churn, etc.
The right measure selection depends on business priorities, seller roles and what the company can administer, without making the plan too complicated to understand.
Breaking Down ARR and ACV
Let’s pause here and explore ARR and ACV. These two measures can look similar, especially for a flat, one-year subscription. However, they answer different questions.
- ARR asks: “What is the recurring revenue run rate at this point in time?”
- ACV asks: “What annualized contract value did we book over a period of time?”
|
Calculation Example | ||
|
Scenario: A seller sells a two-year, committed contract worth $240,000 in January. | ||
|
Measure |
January FY2026 |
January FY2027 |
|
Total contract value |
$240,000 |
$0 |
|
Annual contract value |
$120,000 |
$0 |
|
Annual recurring revenue |
$120,000 |
$120,000 Note: An ARR measure provides the seller quota and credit in FY2027 for ARR that they can’t impact. |
A Closer Look at ARR
ARR is a point-in-time financial metric. It’s generally defined as the annualized monthly recurring revenue (MRR × 12) at a specific date. This metric reflects all the recurring revenue, including all the deferred ARR from contracts sold in prior periods. It’s not simply the value of deals signed by that date, and it shouldn’t be confused with recognized revenue under accounting rules.
There are multiple ARR measures based on desired sales motions to reward (see table below).
|
Measure |
What It Is |
|
New-logo ARR |
ARR from newly acquired customers |
|
Install-base ARR |
ARR from the existing customer base |
|
Total ARR |
ARR from both new and existing customers |
|
Incremental ARR |
The difference between ending ARR and beginning ARR for a defined period |
Because total ARR includes deferred recurring revenue from contracts sold in prior periods, it doesn’t just focus on what the seller can control or influence in the current performance period. Therefore, it’s more appropriate to use incremental ARR that rewards growth. However, using incremental ARR adds complexity to quota setting and plan administration. Companies must account for seasonal business changes and deal timing variances. Additionally, period-over-period ARR change calculations are complex and may be negative. ACV offers a positive contract-based alternative that can provide a clearer link to what the seller influences, which is booking contracts.
A Closer Look at ACV
ACV is a contract-based booking metric. There are two common ACV definitions used in the marketplace:
- Average ACV is the total contract value divided by the contract term length (in years).
- First-year contract value (FYCV) is the first annual contract value of a ramping deal structure to align initial-year contract value with ARR.
Average ACV and FYCV match for uniform pricing structures but diverge for ramping pricing structures. For example, consider a ramping pricing structure of $100,000 in year one, $200,000 in year two and $300,000 in year three.
- For average ACV: The TCV ($600,000) divided by the term length (three years) provides the dollar amount ($200,000).
- For FYCV: The first-year value is $100,000.
Like ARR, there are multiple ACV measures based on desired sales motions to reward (see table below).
|
Measure |
What It Is |
|
New-logo ACV |
ACV from newly acquired customers |
|
Expand ACV |
Incremental ACV from existing customers through upselling more units, increasing pricing, cross-selling more products or selling to new buyers |
|
Renewal ACV |
ACV retained from contracts available to renew (ATR) |
|
Churn ACV |
ACV lost due to customer departures or downgrades from contracts available to renew (ATR) |
These measures can be combined to support different role responsibilities (see table below).
|
Measure |
What It Is (Formula) |
|
New ACV |
New-logo ACV + expand ACV |
|
Install-base ACV |
Renewal ACV + expand ACV |
|
New net-churn ACV |
New-logo ACV + expand ACV − churn ACV |
|
Install-base net-churn ACV |
Expand ACV − churn ACV |
The right ACV measure depends on the sales job’s responsibilities and organizational priorities. For example:
- Use new-logo ACV for hunting roles focused on winning new customers.
- Use separate new ACV and renewal ACV measures when acquisition and expansion need greater emphasis than renewals for full-life-cycle sellers.
- Use new net-churn ACV when renewal rates are high and the business wants one measure that rewards acquisition and expansion while offsetting churn.
Measure selection is only part of the design. Weights, crediting rules and payout curves determine each measure’s relative emphasis.
Reward Multiyear Commitment, Not Duration Alone
Many companies seek multiyear customer commitments even when larger discounts reduce each year’s ARR. Longer-term contracts can strengthen customer commitment, reduce the risk of switching to competitors, give customers time to deploy the solution, as well as realize value and make recurring revenue more predictable.
Companies can reward multiyear commitments in several ways. TCV credits the full commitment but can inflate quota attainment and payouts when contract terms exceed quota assumptions without increasing in-year ARR. ACV annualizes contract value, making deals more comparable and providing a closer link to annual recurring value. However, ACV doesn’t inherently reward longer terms. To encourage multiyear deals, companies can supplement ACV with a bonus, credit uplift or provide partial outyear credit. Another option is to reduce ACV credit for contracts that fall short of the desired multiyear term. The right approach depends on the company’s multiyear strategy, contract terms and pricing practices.
Be the Advisor Who Makes the Definitions Stick
Sales compensation professionals translate business priorities into plans sellers understand. They bring sales, revenue operations, finance and HR stakeholders together to define measures and how they will be defined.
For each measure, agree on four essentials:
- Strategy. “What business outcome and seller behavior should the measure reinforce?”
- Definition. “What value is included or excluded, and how is it calculated?”
- Data source/availability. “What system is the source of record, and how frequently can it be shared with the sellers?”
- Administration. “How will quotas, adjustments, exceptions and disputes be managed?”
Test the rules against realistic deal scenarios before launch (e.g., a new customer, early renewal, co-term agreement, a downgrade, a ramping multiyear contract, an account transfer). If stakeholders can’t explain the result consistently, the plan isn’t ready.
Compensation Closers
Here are a few parting thoughts:
- Consistent metric definitions and reliable data are essential when artificial intelligence (AI) tools support sales compensation analytics. For example, a company may have four different ARR definitions, resulting in a misleading analysis and incorrect insights. A shared definition can ensure automated analysis produces meaningful results.
- The best measure isn’t the most sophisticated one. The simplest measure supports strategy, reflects what the role can influence, can be administered accurately and is easy to understand. When those conditions are met, the result is a practical language for aligning performance and pay.
Editor’s Note: Additional Content
For more information and resources related to this article, see the pages below, which offer quick access to all WorldatWork content on these topics: